Transparency data

Board meeting minutes: 29 January 2019

Published 1 April 2019

Single Source Regulations Office

Minutes of the 25th Board Meeting Board Room, Finlaison House, 15-17 Furnival Street, London EC4A 1AB

Tuesday 29 January 2019 2:00pm to 4:30pm

Board members present: Others present:
George Jenkins (Chairman) Graham Payne
Mary Davies Colin Hill
Peter Freeman Malcolm Botting
Terence Jagger Colin Sharples (item 4)
David Johnston Justine Wharton (item 4)
Marta Phillips Simon Mahony (item 5)
Neil Swift Dagmar Jeschin (item 9)
Matthew Rees Steve Dunsmuir, Hex Security (item 9)
David Galpin

1. Welcome, apologies, announcements and declarations of interest

1.1. 皇冠体育app Chairman welcomed members to the 25th meeting of the Board.

1.2. 皇冠体育appre were no apologies.

1.3. 皇冠体育app Chairman noted that the register of interests on the SSRO鈥檚 website had been updated since the last meeting.

1.4. 皇冠体育app Chairman had received a letter from the Minister for Defence Procurement confirming that David Johnston would be reappointed for a second term as a non-executive Board member.

1.5. Colin Hill had joined the SSRO as Defence Advisor and was welcomed to the meeting as an attendee.

No interests were declared

2. Minutes of 24th meeting of the Board and action tracker

2.1. 皇冠体育app Chairman introduced the minutes of the Board meeting held on 4 December 2018.

2.2. Five actions were recorded on the separate action tracker and had been completed or were reported on in papers elsewhere on the agenda. At the previous meeting Andrew Forzani, Chief Commercial Officer at the MOD, had informed the Board that appointments had been made to key positions on the commercial side at the DIO and SDA. In response to a question about engagement with the new appointees, the Chief Executive confirmed that meetings had been arranged with all.

2.3. 皇冠体育app minutes of the 24th meeting of the Board were approved as a correct record.

3. Chief Executive鈥檚 Report to Board

3.1. Neil Swift, Chief Executive, presented his report to the Board, which provided an update on items not included elsewhere on the agenda.

3.2. 皇冠体育app Chief Executive informed the Board that he and the Chairman had given a presentation to the Defence Industries Council on 21 January. 皇冠体育app presentation had been positive and had focused on the SSRO鈥檚 professionalism and independence, its recent work and immediate plans. Following the presentation, the discussion with members of the Council had covered the benefits of visits to industry; the views of the investment community; the role of the SSRO; and wider knowledge and understanding of the regime. 皇冠体育app Board considered the table of information within the report regarding stakeholder engagement, and it was agreed that NEBM engagement should be included specifically in future. Action: Neil Swift.

3.3. 皇冠体育app Board discussed a matter that had arisen at the Reporting and IT Sub group meeting on 22 January regarding data security. 皇冠体育app Chief Executive had written to the MOD about the issue and would keep the Board informed of the outcome. Action: Neil Swift.

3.4. An interim survey had recently been undertaken on staff engagement and the overall score for staff engagement had increased, with positive movement on all questions. 皇冠体育app next full survey would be circulated in February 2019 in time for staff engagement to be reported in the 2018/19 Annual Report and Accounts as one of the SSRO鈥檚 key performance indicators.

3.5. Following the October 2018 budget commitment to enhance the role of the UK Regulators Network, a 25 per cent annual fee increase for each regulator had been discussed and agreed. 皇冠体育app Chief Executive confirmed that this could be accommodated within the SSRO鈥檚 budget and the Board noted the increase.

3.6. 皇冠体育app Board considered the comparison provided of the SSRO鈥檚 current travel and subsistence rates with those of the MOD and discussed whether it would be appropriate to adopt the MOD鈥檚 rates across all categories. Following discussion, the Board agreed to adopt the MOD鈥檚 rates for accommodation only, in line with the recommendation. This was considered more appropriate and reflective of market rates than the SSRO鈥檚 current rates.

3.7. 皇冠体育app lease on Finlaison House was due to expire in June 2023 and the SSRO was required to provide notice by March 2022. All arms鈥� length bodies were being considered for relocation outside of London and the South East of England at lease events unless there was a clear operational and business need for them to remain. 皇冠体育app SSRO had been in contact with the Places for Growth team in the Cabinet Office and the Government Property Unit, and a range of possible options were being considered. A business case for the SSRO鈥檚 future accommodation would be prepared, and the Board discussed issues relating to its development.

皇冠体育app Board:

  • noted the information provided in the report; and
  • approved the SSRO鈥檚 adoption of the MOD鈥檚 accommodation rates.

4. Corporate Plan

4.1. David Galpin, Director of Legal and Policy, introduced a report updating the Board on progress with the development of the SSRO鈥檚 Corporate Plan for 2019- 2022. A draft Corporate Plan had been developed following the Board鈥檚 discussion on 4 December 2018 and reflected the indicative corporate budget for 2019/20.

4.2. 皇冠体育app Plan set out several priorities for the next three years including: the review of legislation in 2020; reporting requirements; the profit review; the forthcoming tailored review of the SSRO; and specific areas where the need for further or more developed guidance had been identified.

4.3. 皇冠体育app key performance indicators for each objective had been reviewed, with a mixture of quantitative and qualitative indicators included. While several were retained from the previous Plan to ensure continuity and comparability, others had been changed where they were no longer relevant or where a different metric was considered to be a better measure of the organisation鈥檚 performance. Board members discussed the targets against which some of the KPIs would be measured, including those related to compliance and engagement. It was agreed that the KPI on the quality of report submissions would be considered during the next review of the compliance methodology. Action: David Galpin.

4.4. 皇冠体育app Executive Committee had developed an internal business plan setting out more specific work and resource plans for the financial year 2019/20. 皇冠体育app internal business plan would be for internal, operational purposes only.

4.5. 皇冠体育app Board considered the areas of focus in the Plan and noted that flexibility was required around resourcing of referrals and analysis, and that other areas of work could be delayed or reduced to compensate for increased activity in that area.

4.6. Board members discussed several areas of the Plan, including:

  • the definitional differences between objectives 6 and 7 and whether these two objectives could be reordered or joined together;
  • whether the SSRO should be more proactive in developing a suite of reports that would enable users to get better use out of the data in the DefCARS system; and
  • agreement that the wording of the section in the Plan stating that the SSRO does not generate savings or have targets to do so should be reconsidered.

4.7. Board members were complimentary about the design and layout of the Plan. 皇冠体育app final plan would be presented to the Board for approval on 28 March 2019, following a period of consultation with stakeholders.

皇冠体育app Board:

  • commented on the draft Corporate Plan;
  • approved sending the draft Corporate Plan to the MOD, ADS and all defence contractor members of the Operational Working Group for feedback;
  • delegated authority to the Chairman, after consultation with the Chief Executive, to sign off the final document before publication on 31 January; and
  • agreed that a four-week consultation period should be allowed for feedback.

5. Data strategy

5.1. Matthew Rees, Director of Economics and Regulation, introduced the SSRO鈥檚 draft data strategy for the information provided in statutory reports. 皇冠体育app strategy, which had been developed through significant engagement across the SSRO, explained the SSRO鈥檚 vision for the use of the data: that the data submitted by contractors in statutory reports was fully utilised in procurement decisions, contract management and the development of the regulatory framework to deliver value for money and fair and reasonable prices. 皇冠体育app strategy signalled the SSRO鈥檚 commitment to data quality and explained the importance of engagement with industry and the MOD.

5.2. 皇冠体育app data strategy would be released for consultation with stakeholders at the same time as the SSRO鈥檚 Corporate Plan and would be brought back to the Board for consideration in June, before the final version was published in July. 皇冠体育app Board endorsed the direction of the strategy and members hoped that it would encourage debate during the consultation.

5.3. 皇冠体育app Board asked for a review of some specific wording in the strategy, for example around accessibility. 皇冠体育app Board also asked for the consultation response form to include a question about the ambition of the strategy. Action: Matthew Rees.

皇冠体育app Board:

  • agreed that the SSRO should consult on the proposed data strategy;
  • agreed to the data strategy for consultation in Appendix 1 and the consultation document and response form in Appendix 2 should be the basis of the consultation; and
  • agreed to the timetable for next steps (section 4).

6. Annual review of Board effectiveness

6.1. 皇冠体育app Chairman introduced his annual review of the Board鈥檚 effectiveness and thanked Board members for the views they had provided through a questionnaire and recent individual meetings. This engagement had provided assurance to the Chairman that the SSRO Board was effective and that the right governance and controls were in place.

6.2. 皇冠体育app Board discussed the report and its recommendations, considering specifically:

  • the fourth recommendation, that the content of the Corporate Performance Report should be reviewed in response to Board feedback to ensure that it was focused on relevant operational or people issues; and
  • the first recommendation, regarding the separation of items on Board agendas between strategy and corporate items. It was suggested that the Board could increase its focus on strategy, for example through away days and specific discussions on strategic issues.

6.3. Marta Phillips was invited to provide feedback on the Chairman鈥檚 own performance in chairing the Board, based on the questionnaire responses received. She reported that in all areas the majority of members were content with the focus of meetings, use of time, and the way meetings were organised. Board members were also content with the communications between meetings and during Board meetings.

皇冠体育app Board:

  • approved the recommendations from the Board effectiveness review 2019.

7. Corporate Performance Report

7.1. Graham Payne, Interim Director of Corporate Resources, introduced the report, which provided an update to the Board on how the organisation was delivering against its corporate priorities as set out in the Corporate Plan. 皇冠体育app Board considered progress against each of the objectives and the KPI ratings set out in the report.

皇冠体育app Board:

  • reviewed and commented on the Corporate Performance Report.

8. Impact of a no-deal Brexit

8.1. Graham Payne introduced a report providing an update on the implications of a 鈥榥o deal鈥� Brexit for the SSRO, including the impact on the SSRO鈥檚 workforce. 皇冠体育app MOD鈥檚 Permanent Secretary had written to his department and to arms鈥� length bodies including the SSRO to inform recipients of the Cabinet decision that the principal focus for the public sector should now be on ensuring that plans and mitigations for a possible 鈥榥o deal鈥� scenario should be in place. 皇冠体育app Board considered the wider points made in the paper about the implications and preparations for a 鈥榥o deal鈥� Brexit, and how the SSRO could support the MOD in its preparations.

皇冠体育app Board:

  • noted the report.

9. Presentation on cyber-security

9.1. 皇冠体育app Chairman introduced a presentation on cyber-security, which he had asked to be provided in view of the importance of the issue to the SSRO鈥檚 work. 皇冠体育app 30-minute presentation was provided by Steve Dunsmuir from Hex Security, who had advised the SSRO on cyber-security since 2015. 皇冠体育app presentation covered the national cyber risk as well as the SSRO鈥檚 specific position. At its conclusion the Board discussed the issues raised and made points relating to the information held by the SSRO, the assessment provided of the SSRO鈥檚 performance and planned future initiatives.

9.2. 皇冠体育app Board thanked Steve Dunsmuir for his useful and informative presentation and noted that the issues covered had provided assurance about the arrangements the SSRO had in place. In concluding the item the Chairman noted that it was important for the Board and Audit Committee to continue monitoring this issue.

10. Minutes of the 26 November 2018 Regulatory Committee and update from 23 January 2019 Regulatory Committee

10.1.Peter Freeman presented the minutes of the Regulatory Committee meeting on 26 November 2018 and provided an overview of the meeting on 23 January 2019.

10.2.At its January meeting the Regulatory Committee had agreed the baseline profit rate, capital servicing rates for fixed capital and working capital, and the SSRO funding adjustment for 2019/20 that would be recommended to the Secretary of State. 皇冠体育app Committee had discussed DefCARS at length and was conscious of the importance of the system to the organisation鈥檚 standing. It had also considered and agreed revisions to the pricing guidance.

皇冠体育app Board:

  • noted the minutes

11. Future Board business

11.1.皇冠体育app Chairman presented to the Board a two-page document showing the business of all Board and sub-committee meetings until January 2020. 皇冠体育app Board noted the content of the report.

皇冠体育app Board:

  • Commented on the future Board business.

12. Any Other Business

12.1.皇冠体育app next meeting of the Board would take place on 28 March 2019 at 2:00pm